Friday, February 26, 2010

Inside the Insurgency

Once again, PBS Frontline is pushing the journalistic envelope in order to provide pioneering coverage of the war in Afghanistan. Their most recent contribution, entitled "Behind Taliban Lines", is a rare documentation of insurgent life and an ominous snapshot of global jihad. Afghani journalist Najibullah Quraishi spent an unprecedented 10 days within the ranks of an elusive militant cell operating in the north country. It is a rare and unsettling opportunity to follow the footsteps of these men as they travel from guesthouse to guesthouse attempting to plot and execute acts of sabotage on Allied vehicles. Theirs is a makeshift but implacable resistance. Each is prepared for martyrdom and devoutly committed to eliminating the "unbelievers". It should be said, the film does little to alleviate the foreboding sense of futility that continues to haunt this 9-year-old conflict. It is pretty sobering stuff. It is also infuriating.

This posse of self-righteous guerillas seems to traverse the frontier with relative impunity. They live off the local charity of some and prey on the fears of others- it is often hard to distinguish between the two. Sadly, they seem to represent only one tiny head of the large, slippery, seething Hydra that plagues our efforts in the region. Decapitation only feeds the beast. It would seem that the task before us is no less daunting than those of Greek mythology.....but I would not want to attach a false narrative.

You can view the film here:

Thursday, February 18, 2010

Power of the Portrait

There is probably no sight more evocative and mysterious than the human face. In a matter of milliseconds, each peculiar visage supplies our brain with a unique cognitive gestalt that is inundated with cryptic information. A slight tilt of the mouth, a furrow over the eyes, a crook in the nose, or a bump on the chin- every subtle detail, every faint gesture is a precious insight into an elusive foreign psyche.

Taken by Russian photographer Gleb Kosorukov, these images of modern-day Ukrainian coal miners demonstrate the rare power of the portrait to stimulate and engross the subconscious. What exactly do we "see" when we look at such photos? What mental imagery gets churned up each time our gaze falls on another? Perhaps, if we can come to understand how one brief snapshot of reality calls on our cache of memory and emotion, we may begin to unlock some of the latent complexities of our own thought. With extraordinary images such as these, sometimes it is both fun and instructive to explore the mystery further.

First off, the most striking aspect of this image has to be the dramatic irony. Amazingly, it seems totally conceivable that the same shot could have been captured almost 150 years ago with little to no alteration. It invades the mind like a relic from a bygone Age of Man.... an era of titanic industrial might and mass human drudgery. As your eye follows the coal-creased contours, it's hard not to choke on the festering plumes of particulate matter, to hear the metallic whine & clank of primitive manufacturing, or to sense the plight of a back-broken proletariat. Our plucky subject seems to know the bleak prohpecy of Orwell all to well: "If you want a vision of the future, imagine a boot stamping on the human face- forever."

Yet despite his grim circumstance, his expression projects an unmistakable brand of cheeky bravado- the origins of which we can only hazard a feeble guess. Is it the smirk of Faust after having double-crossed the devil, or just the puckish grin of a coal-cloaked Chesire cat on a long-awaited smoke break? Is he really mining coal, or is he piloting Death back and forth across the river Styx? Is he resurfacing after six-hours work or resurrecting from six-feet under?

For me, the real poignancy lies in a bizarre paradox: as tangibly close as I may feel to this near caricature of blue-collar, black-lung man, and no matter how psychologically suggestive and empathy-encouraging this portrait may be, it embodies a world of experience that I could not be further removed from... and one which I will never approach. Perhaps this is what he's grinning about......

Thursday, February 11, 2010

The Architecture of "Spectacle"

This is a timely new documentary from PBS FRONTLINE entitled Digital Nation. In a nutshell, it explores the vast breadth and depth of the human interaction with cutting-edge media technology and raises some pointed questions about the inevitable (but often elusive) social implications. Just to name a few, some points of interest include 1) the myth of media multi-tasking, 2) gaming and internet "rescue camps" in South Korea, 3) the erosion of memory & literacy 4) the bizarro "World of Warcraft", 5) telecommuting in "Second Life", and 6) the murky ethics of Predator drones and US Army recruitment "arcades".

If anything, the film is a sobering portrait of the present state of the hyperreal. As the speed of such technology is only accerlating, it is with extreme vigilance and introspection that we should engage such titanic, life-altering advances.
 

Saturday, February 6, 2010

Jon Stewart v Bill O'Reilly

Once again, Stewart and O'Reilly sit down for a jovial and gentlemanly conversation. If there's anyone on the "left" who needs to teach a clinic on managing O'Reilly's on-camera persona, it's Jon Stewart. The only problem is that it's not really a talent one can impart to others. Without question, he is the undisputed master of sword-and-shield debate. In his case, exploiting the unique power of humor to placate and disarm an adversary before delivering shrewd points of argument. O'Reilly needs to feel in constant control of the conversation, and Stewart dances back-and-forth over this requirement like James Brown in a third encore.

As it is a favorite topic of this blog, I also love to see Stewart press the issue of narrative.

Here's the full, unedited interview which, of course, was only made available online:

Monday, February 1, 2010

Deconstructing the Decision

For an excellent discussion of the recent Supreme Court case, I highly suggest listening to this Bill Moyers interview. He sits down with the attorneys from both sides for an intelligent and civil debate. (Part II also includes good back and forth between both sides)


Part I: Floyd Abrams (representing Citzens United)

and

Part II: Trevor Potter (representing the Federal Election Commission)

And some good-natured ribbing from the usual suspects....

Colbert on "Precedon't":

The Colbert ReportMon - Thurs 11:30pm / 10:30c
The Word - Prece-Don't
www.colbertnation.com
Colbert Report Full EpisodesPolitical HumorEconomy


Stewart on conquering "corporate repression":

The Daily Show With Jon StewartMon - Thurs 11p / 10c
Supreme Corp
www.thedailyshow.com
Daily Show
Full Episodes
Political HumorHealth Care Crisis

Thursday, January 28, 2010

Fork Stuck in Supreme Court

If you waited patiently until the 45th min of the President’s speech last night, you were privileged to catch a glimpse of the pathetically cavalier attitude with which Washington regards campaign finance reform. The paragraph of lip service Obama allotted to the Court’s recent landmark decision expressed the same sense of gravity and urgency one would exhibit in taking a late afternoon nap. Let’s just hit the snooze button and hope we don’t sleep through dinner. Personally, I think the occasion called for more William Jennings Bryan and less Rip Van Winkle.

But so it goes....the Supreme Court’s ruling is just another contentious round in the age-old grudge-match between Liberty & Equality. And once again, the all-seducing narcotic of "freedom" has foiled reasonable measures to ensure a semblance of fairness in the political process. Under the guise of protecting free speech, the majority opinion was an unmistakable victory for the well-financed establishment. My only question is: why the public outrage?? Shouldn’t the average citizen expect a windfall of "trickle-down" democratic justice? Isn't what's good for the plutocracy good for everyone? I’m pretty sure that Monsanto and Exxon will have my best interest in mind when they start planning their election season propaganda campaign. I’m also quite sure that progressive candidates don’t need to fear crippling media reprisals should they take policy stances in conflict with business.

In all seriousness, it was only a matter of time before corporate henchmen were able to dismantle the modest gains of campaign finance reformers. The ugly marriage between money and politics is far too co-dependent for any lasting partition. The principled few who are brave (or crazy) enough to stand in the way of this grotesque confluence risk suffering the following education of Network's Howard Beale:



The bottom line is that this trend is nothing new. This Court's ruling is just the most recent application of "laissez-faire" political philosophy- but it's clear the contagion is spreading beyond the sphere of economics. It's another manifestation of the epic quest to undo every rational constraint on the corrupting potential of highly concentrated wealth. According to our esteemed judiciary, multi-national corporations do not have enough political voice. Forget their legions of lobbyists. Forget the fact that their ad dollars underwrite (and therefore unduly influence) most outlets of mass communication. Let's tip the scales a bit more.

This is not to imply that the American business community is either monolithic or inherently evil in their political posture. Of course, they're not. However, they are all unified in at least one respect: their unending pursuit for profit. What's wrong with a tidy profit? Absolutely nothing, in and of itself. The problem begins when the institutional constructs that maintain a logical distance between commercial and social life are completely eroded; when quarterly earnings are exalted above all other social and democratic considerations; when behemoth conglomerates entirely removed from the long term welfare of citizen and country are allowed to penetrate and overwhelm every facet of human life. It is the moment where we forfeit our collective humanity and become faceless, interchangeable consumers conditioned to worship our wants over our needs. We become a culture awash in hollow, commodified diversions where the illusion of "freedom" and fulfillment are promised, but only a gilded poverty is delivered:

(This ad is brilliant.)



It sounds like an Orwellian farce, but is it that much further from the present? Just how far down the rabbit hole are we? We already live in a media-saturated world funded almost entirely through corporate patronage- where news is sold as entertainment and politics is presented as sport or scandal. Should we really expect progress when we're trapped in a perverse paradigm that breeds ignorance and compromises truth for the sake of ratings???..... Welcome to the Society of the Spectacle.

Wednesday, January 20, 2010

Politics..... Just Saying "No".

Given the rising tide of American political ennui, these videos should come in extremely handy. In fact, the wunderkinder over at "The Onion" placed this one in their "Most Vital" category. Genius, as always.

By the way, the male anchor in their "Today Now!" series is scary good.



...or if you MUST vote, you can always...

Monday, January 18, 2010

Watching "The Lives of Others"

I saw "The Lives of Others" over the weekend, and would highly recommend it to those interested in a disturbingly good vignette of East German life under the Stazi. In particular, it portrays the all-consuming anxiety (and absurdity) associated with intellectual life in pre-1989 Eastern Europe. Although most cinema offers the audience a modicum of guilty, voyeuristic pleasure, this film turns up the pathos by allowing the viewer to watch the watchers. It doesn't surprise me that it won the Oscar for best foreign language film a few years back.

As westerners, it's nigh impossible for us to imagine (or empathize with) the acute mental stress that besieged those who dwelt in the wall's shadow, but this film will certainly join the canon of work dedicated to facilitating a bona fide attempt. The film's protagonist, Georg Dreyman, evinces many of the crises of conscience (and psychoses) described by Nobel Prize-winning author Czeslaw Milosz in his essential work The Captive Mind. In the following passage, Milosz describes his notion of "aesthetic ketman" or a certain form of psychological resistance to the will of authority:

"Aesthetic ketman is born of the disparity between man's longings and the sense-satisfactions the "New Faith" (Revolutionary Marxism) offers. A man of taste cannot approve the results of official pressure in the realm of culture no matter how much he applauds the latest verses, how many flattering reviews he writes of current art expositions, nor how studiously he pretends that the gloomy new buildings coincide with his personal preferences in architecture. He changes completely within the four walls of his home. There one finds (if he is a well-situated intellectual) reproductions of works of art officially condemned as bourgeois, records of modern music, and a rich collection of ancient authors in various languages. The luxury of splendid isolation is pardoned him so long as his creative work is effective propaganda. To protect his position and his apartment (which he has by the grace of the State), the intellectual is prepared to make any sacrifice or compromise; for the value of privacy in a society that affords little if any isolation is greater than saying "my home is my castle" can lead to one to surmise." (pg. 65)

The film deals with the intricate destruction of this "splendid isolation". Here is the trailer:

Saturday, January 16, 2010

Colbert and Stewart on Haitian Relief

Colbert and Stewart deliver a great, if ironic, message in a world where it's hard to find news coverage that isn't adulterated with political agenda.

Rare candor from the Colbert Nation:

The Colbert ReportMon - Thurs 11:30pm / 10:30c
Haiti Disaster Relief Donations - Kathleen Sebelius
www.colbertnation.com
Colbert Report Full EpisodesPolitical HumorEconomy



Stewart nails it again:

The Daily Show With Jon StewartMon - Thurs 11p / 10c
Haiti Earthquake Reactions
www.thedailyshow.com
Daily Show
Full Episodes
Political HumorHealth Care Crisis

Friday, January 8, 2010

The War on "The War on Terror"


Building on the point of false narratives (below), this is Scott Ritter's sweeping indictment of the "WOT" narrative. Pretty compelling stuff. The full article is definitely worth a read, but here's a snapshot:

"The “war on terror” into which Obama seems to have thrust himself (the most recent manifestation being Yemen) remains the largest obstacle for any rational resolution of America’s problems in Iraq, Iran, Afghanistan and Pakistan. Simply put, so long as the United States seeks an enemy that does not exist, it will always be looking for an enemy in its stead. The “war on terror” has the United States combing the world in search of enemies, and because American policymakers are responsive not to the reality that exists in the world today, but rather the perceptions of an American people largely ignorant of the world in which they live, and paralyzed by the fear such ignorance generates, there will always be countries and causes America will anoint as foe."

... the solution to these problems rests not in defining new parameters for action, but rather in the definition of the basic problems faced. From an overarching perspective, the United States needs to realize that there is no “war on terror,” and as such no “enemy” for us to close with and destroy. The human condition has always produced those who would seek to do harm to society. Norms and standards have been adopted, in almost universal fashion, that define how humans, organized into communities and nations, should interact in dealing with such deviations. This body of rules and regulations is collectively “the rule of law,” the principle of which defines modern society.

Deviations from the “rule of law” are best dealt with in collective fashion by those who share not only common values but also a common interest in such a resolution. Giving a criminal element, whether in the form of al-Qaida or a drug lord, the status of community or nation by waging “war” against it represents a failure to define the problem properly, leading inevitably to solutions that solve nothing. The answer to 9/11 is not war, but rather the “rule of law.” Until this underlying premise is recognized and adopted by U.S. policymakers, the psychosis of war will continue to corrupt American policy, and with it American society."


His solution in a nutshell: drop the WOT BS and deal with Palestine and Kashmir- the real issues.


Tuesday, January 5, 2010

The Siren Call of False Narratives


I'd like to start off the new year by taking a moment to pause and reflect on one of the most powerful weapons in the media arsenal (and a prime obsession of mine): the notion of narrative. This entry is a bit longer than most, but I hope you'll indulge me because it's a rather important topic- and I hope you'll find it interesting. Please note: this treatment is FAR from exhaustive. Those interested in further reading should consult the work of Berkeley Professor George Lakoff particularly Metaphors We Live By and The Political Mind.

If media perform any principal task, it is the construction of narratives- or basic storytelling. The diversity of facts and details the world has to offer is boundless, but the amount of meaningful narratives is relatively finite. (Think why so many Hollywood films seem to utilize the same plotlines.) Without the framework of some type of narrative, the human mind sputters to extract any meaning from media messages. Without a perceived narrative context, information floats like an indiscernible morass of minutiae. This is so much the case that if message producers do not provide a credible narrative to frame the facts, our brains will instinctively scour our memory for the most salient, ready-made narratives to fill this critical void.

The point is that narratives are what provide meaning in our lives- they organize the chaos of sensory data into convenient frames of time and space so that we may better understand how to orient our lives in an incredibly complex world. In fact, we are conditioned to recognize the traditional catalogue of narratives from a very early age (Walt Disney created an empire on this fact). We learn the hero is inherently good and the villain is evil incarnate; we know the grammar of the hero's quest instinctually and we know how we will feel at any given point in the story whether it's a "rags-to-riches" or "boy meets girl" tale. These emotions are not arbitrary, but are organized to promote specific moral principles passed down from one generation to the next. From Homer's Odyssey to Lucas' Star Wars, we repeatedly encounter these "deep narratives" via media representation. As a result of this diligent indoctrination, most of us come to interpret our own lives through these essential epics- after all, what is our own life if not a story with us as the protagonist.

From a psychological perspective, narratives constitute a valuable cognitive expedient. There is no physical way our brains can digest and compute every single fluttering detail the lived world has to offer- we have to sacrifice a great deal of earthly complexity in order to make informed generalizations based on our "best" judgment. Therefore, we are often less attentive to isolated features than we are to patterns of features. This is to say that our brains think metaphorically because it provides the best economy in cognition. It's the patterns that provide us with the most meaning not the details. Details are important, but only in so far as they help us recognize a pattern. Similarly, facts are important, but only in so far as they help us construct a credible narrative.

The problem is that once we recognize and apply a given pattern/narrative in our thinking, we are more likely to try to apply this same pattern in other circumstances where there may only be a vague resemblance. It's been scientifically proven that narratives are self-reinforcing (in the cognitive sense)- our brains become biased towards seeing these old patterns versus seeing something new or "out of the ordinary". In our cognitive scramble for meaning, we tend to eschew or ignore the critical details that may render our favorite narratives obsolete or erroneous. (This phenomenon is the same for cultural stereotypes.) To put it another way, we tend to see what we are inclined to see. (Was Saddam Hussein really part of the "War on Terror" narrative?) Our deep narratives form the primary lens through which we try to see the world- we compartmentalize the facts into the finite set of frameworks that we can understand. Unfortunately, reality should not be treated as a pliable substance.

As far as media manipulation goes, the problem is threefold. The first is referenced above: our brains have evolved to over-rely on pattern recognition- we instinctually seek to apply a certain narrative whether the actual facts warrant this or not. In other words, narratives enable and encourage a certain degree of cognitive laziness. We love our narratives, and we want to employ them all the time. Rather than parse through the tedious facts and arrive at a truly enlightened picture, we want the "executive summary" so we can understand the gist of an event and quickly move on. Media producers (especially the unscrupulous vendors of partisan media) are highly aware of this and exploit it by framing the facts to fit a narrative that promotes their objectives. They don't so much provide the breadth of clinical facts as much as they sell a prepackaged narrative with a selection of facts couched to fit the framework. (Watch John Stewart nail this.)

This leads into the second vulnerability: narratives are never neutral, especially when it comes to news. Narratives are heavily-laden with rigid value judgments. The hero is always good; the villain is always despised. If you can believably frame the narrative in your favor, the desired effects are almost guaranteed. And finally, the third (and most important) vulnerability we have as media consumers is the instinctive and often unconscious nature of this cognitive process. We do not consciously decide to feel this way or that way about a certain narrative or representation of facts, it happens automatically. We may consciously feel the emotions attached to the narrative, but we have little control over whether they are elicited or not. Therefore, we may think we are making a "rational" political decision based on a certain objective set of facts, but in reality we are being manipulated at the subconcious level.

In sum: news media use narrative device to provide an essential degree of context in the presentation of world events. However, narrative is often used by less scrupulous actors as a mechanism to prey on the psychological vulnerabilities inherent in the cognitive process. We must be vigilant of this practice. Our narratives should only serve as rough guides to aid our understanding- especially when it comes to our domestic and foreign policy choices. They should be held loosely and abandoned readily. Whether you subscribe to the so-called "War on Terror" narrative or not, we should all be wary of those who seek to apply such frames dogmatically to every international event. Clearly, this is evidence of an agenda. The world is much too complex for such facile frameworks however tempting they are. We must resist the siren call of false narratives and strive for a genuine, impartial pursuit of truth.

Wednesday, December 16, 2009

The Tale of Tyger Woods

I've never really paid much attention to poetry (who does), but I've always had a strange affinity for William Blake. As an eccentric Romantic, his work is vivid with mythological imagery that speaks to mankind's unique psychological conflicts. In particular, his "Songs of Innocence" and "Songs of Experience" are two volumes of allegorical poetry that represent the opposing notions of the ideal and the real world. Some poems (like "The Lamb") in Innocence have antithetical poems (like "The Tyger") in Experience.

I suppose this appeals to me because, like Stevenson's The Strange Case of Dr. Jeykll and Mr. Hyde, the work explores the duality of man and our internal struggle with good and evil. For our purposes here, I find these inquiries exceptionally relevant as they relate to the dichotomy between public and private personas (whether mediated by a television screen, the lens of camera, or your skin). The tale of Tiger Woods is a sadly perfect example of this: the epic journey from his immaculate conception to an inevitable fall from grace. James Suroweicki's latest New Yorker article is a good encapsulation of his peculiar case. Like Blake's innocent Lamb, Woods has been revealed a depraved (and quite human) Tyger. - Bye, bye Accenture.


Tuesday, December 8, 2009

Anatomy of Obama's Defining Moment



In case you missed it over the weekend:
NY Times piece on Obama's decision-making process.

And an excellent PBS Frontline documentary on the AfPak realities including poignant coverage of the US Marines and their experience in Helmand Province:


Wednesday, December 2, 2009

The Gospel According to Colbert

I take comfort in knowing that 3 out of the TOP 5 books on the New York Times bestseller list include Sarah Palin (#1), Glenn Beck (#4), Mike Huckabee (#5). Damn liberal media....

And, just for kicks, here's a pretty funny Onion News clip with a cameo from the messiah himself:



Zombie Reagan Raised From Grave To Lead GOP

Monday, November 30, 2009

Afghanistan: A "Defining Moment"


Over the last few days I've been reading a paperback from the Harvard Business Review entitled On Leadership. The book is just one publication in a long series "designed to bring today's managers and professionals the fundamental information they need to stay competitive in a fast-moving world"- according to the inside flap anyway. As someone relatively detached from the formal world of business and management, I've found most of the book's entries (written by various "esteemed" authors) pleasantly succinct and insightful. Most pieces are eminently digestible and quite relevant to the world at-large. In my reading, one in particular jumped out at me: "The Discipline of Building Character."

I usually skip over any literature that prominently features the word "discipline" or "character", but upon reading the ever-handy "executive summary", I found myself intrigued by the author's conception of a "defining moment." Written by a renowned Business Ethics professor at HBS, the article makes a fundamental distinction between an "ethical decision" and a "defining moment". In the former case, the decision typically involves choosing between two options, one we know to be right and the other to be wrong (in an ethical sense). The later, more interestingly, involves making critical decisions where there is no "right" answer, but rather a number of difficult alternatives with varying and often imperceptible degrees of "rightness". In such cases, the author explains: "no matter which option we choose, we feel like we've come up short." The author's argument is that these so-called defining moments, taken cumulatively over one's life, form the basis of an individual's character.

I like this assertion. Over the course of all our lives, the crucible of character building is more often than not a catalogue of painstaking, introspective decisions. These moments challenge and reveal our core values, our integrity, and our identity. Fundamentally, they are a critical test of authenticity. Who am I? No facade, no bullshit. I think it's fair to say that Afghanistan presents Obama with such a moment writ large. I've followed the so-called AfPak policy making process very closely, and I still struggle haplessly with the search for a profoundly superior course of action. Of course, I'm not privy to the entire US national security apparatus, but I think most candid observers will acknowledge that our options are "not good", "bad", and "worse". I dismiss the knee-jerk capitulation of many politicians to McCrystal's troop request. It wreaks of typical party politics and unvirtuous expediency. In the end, this may be the "best" course of action, but the gravity of this decision demands intense, conscientious deliberation attended by all relevant parties. My hope is that this is what has occurred over the past few weeks.

The unfortunate reality is that we've painted ourselves in a corner in Afghanistan. Like the proverbial red-headed step child, we've ignored it, under-fed it, and starved it of any discipline. Our policy has been adrift for years without any clear sense of military vision or attainable objective. Is it really surprising that the situation has deteriorated drastically? The constellation of serviceable policy options that once existed has now shrunk to a handful of pathetically dour alternatives. I have absolutely no envy for the President's position, but a fine respect for his character. Solemnly, he will do what he thinks is right.

On a final note, it is my sense that the AfPak problem is virtually unmanageable as far as the US is concerned. However, when you are dealing with nuclear weapons (as we are in Pakistan), the risk of simple withdrawal is too high given the current level of instability. The question is, then, can we leave when things are "stable" (whenever this is), or will our leaving cause renewed instability? Are we in for a semi-permanent occupation? And if the long-term goal of this occupation is some sort of stability provided by pseudo-democratic governance and economic development (which is the real problem, along with education/literacy), can this be achieved with our presence. Maybe, but not at the barrel of a gun. Any sustainable solution will involve extraordinary cultural and economic changes that will take generations to occur and will require the involvement of a dedicated multinational coalition. Are we ready, as a global community, to commit trillions more dollars and hundreds more lives? Or will we lose our collective interest (again) once the issue has escaped the media spotlight?

Tuesday, November 24, 2009

The Gospel According to Al

The prescient insights of UHF and the Great Monseigneur of Mock, "Weird" Al Yankovic:







Saturday, November 21, 2009

Paving Over Stalin's Grass

For those of us in the West, it was simply the Berlin Wall; for those to whom it mattered most, it was Antifaschistischer Schutzwall. To understand this distinction is to begin an authentic inquiry into the extraordinary and often subtle implications of 1989. It's hard to imagine that just over twenty years ago, this iconic, and seemingly indelible monument to the Cold War met its end at the hands of those it confined- both physically and psychologically. While recent media coverage has immortalized the event with all the tinsel of nostalgia and ceremony, deep and complex neuroses still cripple many residents of the "emancipated" East. Unfortunately, the explosive demise of East Germany and its festering psychological fallout cannot be sufficiently relayed by the spectacle of broadcast. A genuine pursuit of historical significance requires empathy. And real empathy is not virtual.

A faithful commemoration of “the fall” would entail nothing less than inhabiting the fragile lives of those who dwelt in its menacing shadow for so long. Any attempt to convey this plight in either words or images inevitably falls short. Our strenuous empathy requires the solemn physicality of place. In other words, you have to be there. However, sadly for Berlin, this monument of struggle is now almost totally gone. The notorious wall that interned a generation is quickly vanishing for good. While some may greet this summary extinction with joy or, worse, apathy, I think the complete lack of organized preservation is both harmful and wrong, and tragically represents a much larger social trend.

As its agitprop name suggests, the Antifaschistischer Schutzwall was foisted on the East German public as a prudent solution to keep the “fascist” West at bay lest the “capitalist cannibals” beset the happy collective. In reality, of course, the wall or “death strip” as it was known locally, was a penal rampart with unparalleled, methodical lethality. Stock media images of the relatively innocuous concrete slabs do not approach an accurate portrayal of the inhumanity. More than a barrier, the strip was a complex system of watchtowers, staggered fencing, anti-vehicle trenches, bunkers, and other cruel obstacles designed to kill or disable those daring to trespass (“Stalin’s grass” was the local nickname for the nail-spiked stretch of corridor intended to impale and trap victims’ feet). The soundtrack was equally unforgiving: the incessant, barking rasp of border dogs, the ghoulish crack of sniper fire, and the grinding wail of military vehicles. Taken together, the wall’s imposition on the human soul was immeasurable.

It begs the question: why would anyone want to preserve any vestige of such obscenity? Because it’s history? Yes- but most importantly because it’s ugly and you could never replicate its aura of depravity. No documentary, no blog, no research paper could ever record or evoke the stark drama of place. If we lose our tangible connection to the past, we forfeit a vital piece of our collective identity, and we resign ourselves to a fate where our only relationship with history is through media-sponsored simulation. We enter a frenzied hyperreality that is devoid of authenticity or originality; where the priceless topography of meaning is constantly razed and repurposed at the careless whim of society; where representation totally supplants reality. We become aliens in our own land, the characteristics of which are unrecognizable and always fleeting. We become passengers of a rudderless vessel at the mercy of a mercurial sea. Unanchored to the past in any meaningful way, we drown in the present. Defeated and demoralized we passively submit to the will of the Spectacle. In a very real sense, we ARE all Berliners.


I recognize the irony, but here is a....

...poignant documentary on the Fall:



...and a BRILLIANT fictional film I HIGHLY suggest renting:



SHIG

Monday, November 16, 2009

Charlie and the Tree of Knowledge

If we accept the notion that Sean Hannity is God in the grotesquely metaphorical sense (described in prior post), Charlie Rose might just be the proverbial Tree of Knowledge.

I was watching an episode a few nights back and something peculiar caught my attention. I couldn't articulate it at the time, but after several days, it finally came to me (like Doc Brown and the Flux Capacitor): Charlie Rose was, indeed, the "answer" to the Spectacle of Hannity. I've had great affection for Charlie and the show for some time, but this cosmic revelation was a refreshingly new, visceral sense of enlightenment. It seems the molecules for this "Eureka!" had always been present in mind but, until this morning, had lingered deep under the surface, twinkling quietly in my subconscious like stars in a distant galaxy. As with any revelatory episode, I wanted to examine the causes and excavate for any truth- could I deconstruct the glow of the light bulb? Let us explore.

It so happened that the interviews featured on the particular program in question were with Steven Levitt, of Freakonomics fame, and Malcolm Gladwell, of Blink, Tipping Point, et cetera. Both gentleman are highly celebrated for their uncanny ability to refine fascinating insights from seemingly banal human activity. They've carved out a wonderfully lucrative niche as venerable princes of pop-sociology. However, what struck me about their interviews (and what precipitated my epiphany) was that both men emphasized a central theme: the latent splendor of life. Levitt put it more inductively: "It's about asking the right questions." Gladwell put it succinctly: "you have to train yourself that everything is interesting". Then it hit me: this is the unspoken mantra of Charlie Rose- in precious few words, this is why I love the show.

Charlie Rose is a shining affirmation of this terribly unsung dictum. Everything is interesting, but only if you look closely and honestly, without pride or prejudice. As Charlie so effortlessly demonstrates, exploring the exceptional complexity of the world requires two critical assets: an open mind and the ability to listen- this is the Charlie Rose calling card. Not simply listening as in absorbing and processing sound waves, but listening in the much broader, more active sense: hearing, thinking, feeling, assessing, evaluating, studying, exploring and reacting in kind. The art and science of listening.

Similarly, Charlie is the embodiment of the open mind- but not simply an open mind in the sense of impartiality, but rather a governing ethos guided by a childlike curiosity for everything- an intellectual wanderlust. An insatiable appetite for all knowledge. Whether he's interviewing Warren Buffet, Charles Manson, LeBron James, or Jay Z, Charlie has an unmatched ability to elicit extraordinary stories from subjects of all stripes. The viewer doesn't need to avidly follow politics, sports, economics, film, or what-have-you in order to become engrossed in the program because, fundamentally, all people are interesting in some way- it only needs to be drawn out of them artfully. This is what Charlie does better than anyone else, but more still, he does it on every show, every night, across the breadth of the human stage. No agenda. Knowledge for its own sake.

Amid the intolerable din and tawdry bunting that comprise the phantasmagoria of modern television, Charlie Rose has somehow managed to preserve the fleeting virtues of nobility, integrity, and grace. The narcotic allure of Eden, with its Glenn Beck and its Girls Next Door, is strong but not absolute. His Tree of Knowledge continues to promise emancipation from the confining logic of the Spectacle and an escape from a captivity of diversion and exploitation. Those who partake in the forbidden fruit must submit to a new awareness and risk the retribution of God.

SHIG